Alphabet Inc's Google has shut down a service it provided to wireless carriers globally that showed them weak spots in their network coverage, people familiar with the matter told Reuters, because of Google's concerns that sharing data from users of its Android phone system might attract the scrutiny of users and regulators.
The withdrawal of the service, which has not been previously reported, has disappointed wireless carriers that used the data as part of their decision-making process on where to extend or upgrade their coverage. Even though the data were anonymous and the sharing of it has become commonplace, Google’s move illustrates how concerned the company has become about drawing attention amid a heightened focus in much of the world on data privacy.
Google's Mobile Network Insights service, which had launched in March 2017, was essentially a map showing carriers signal strengths and connection speeds they delivered in each area.
The service was provided free to carriers and vendors that helped them manage operations. The data came from devices running Google’s Android operating system, which is on about 75 percent of the world's smartphones, making it a valuable resource for the industry.
It used data only from users who had opted into sharing location history and usage and diagnostics with Google. The data were aggregated, meaning they did not explicitly link any information to any individual phone user. It included data relating to a carrier's own service and that of competitors, which were not identified by name.
Nevertheless, Google shut down the service in April due to concerns about data privacy, four people with direct knowledge of the matter told Reuters. Some of them said secondary reasons likely included challenges ensuring data quality and connectivity upgrades among carriers being slow to materialize.
Google spokeswoman Victoria Keough confirmed the move but declined to elaborate, saying only that changing "product priorities" were behind it. Google’s notice to carriers when it shut down the service did not specify a reason, two of the four people told Reuters.
"We worked on a program to help mobile partners improve their networks through aggregated and anonymized performance metrics," Keough said. "We remain committed to improving network performance across our apps and services for users."
Closer scrutiny
The loss of Google’s service is the latest example of an internet company opting to end a data-sharing service rather than risk a breach or further scrutiny from lawmakers. The European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation, introduced last year, prohibits companies sharing user data with third parties without users’ explicit consent or a legitimate business reason.
US and European lawmakers have stepped up their focus on how tech companies treat user data after a series of large-scale data security failures and the revelation that Facebook Inc improperly shared data on 87 million of its users with political consultancy Cambridge Analytica.
In April, Google shut down its Video Checkup service from its YouTube operation, which it launched in mid-2017 to let customers in Malaysia compare their provider's streaming capability in a specific spot with other carriers. YouTube spokeswoman Mariana De Felice cited "relatively low user engagement" with Video Checkup for its retirement, which has not been previously reported.
Facebook has begun reviewing data deals with app developers and the four big US wireless carriers recently stopped selling data on customers' real-time locations to marketers and other firms.
Walking a tightrope
Internet companies now walk a tightrope in trying to generate revenue or improve their services by supplying user data to other companies because they risk compromising – or appearing to compromise – data privacy. And companies including Google and Facebook have curtailed access to data by outside companies over the past two years.
Google's Mobile Network Insights service was not the only source of detailed customer data used by carriers to determine where cell tower upgrades are needed, but it was useful because of the sheer volume of Android phones in the market.
It was an "independent reference from the horse’s mouth, so you couldn't get any better than this," said Mushil Mustafa, a former employee at Dubai-based carrier du. "But the carriers have investments in other tools, obviously."
Facebook offers a similar service, called Actionable Insights. Facebook appears committed to continuing the service but declined to comment when asked.
Data-sharing arrangements between tech companies became common over the past decade as the use of smartphones and apps exploded, but what data is collected and how it is shared is not always clear to users.
Companies often are not explicit about their data sharing. Google's data policy that Android users agree to states that it may collect and share network connection quality information. Wireless carriers had not been specifically mentioned as recipients.
As users demand greater transparency, what constitutes a violation of consumer trust is not clear.
Facebook's Actionable Insights service for carriers also includes information about users’ gender, age and other characteristics collected from its apps, which helps carriers spot demographic trends to target their marketing, but it does not tie data to specific individuals.
"We have publicly announced this program and carefully designed it to protect people's privacy," said Facebook spokesman Joe Osborne, in a statement.
Google said it shared neither aggregated nor individualised data on user demographics and app usage. The company rejected requests to give equipment vendors any data, it said.
- Reuters
