Socialist party PSM has slammed "weak" civil society and Pakatan Harapan leaders for their too-swift alliance with former prime minister Dr Mahathir Mohamad in signing the citizens' declaration to oust Prime Minister Najib Abdul Razak, which they claim is as good as affirming Umno-BN rule.

"The press conference only proves how weak in strength and in ideas the opposition and civil society really are. Unable to settle squabbling among themselves, they have decided to ally with any ex-dictator who made the same call," said its secretary-general A Sivarajan in a statement.

He noted that Harapan leaders' signature on the document was as good as them signing a declaration which indirectly affirmed Umno-BN rule.

"Any short-term plan to remove only the cancerous leader but maintain rule of the same dominant party spells disaster for future Malaysian politics," he said.

He pointed out glaring issues in the declaration, saying Harapan and civil society cannot really believe that Mahathir and the coalition would be allowed to do significant structural changes within the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission, the police, and the judiciary while Umno-BN is still in power.

Authoritarian legacy

Sivarajan also highlighted the vague wording and structure of the declaration.

“What next? How will it be executed? What executive power does the coalition have? Who is calling the shots in this coalition? Is it a democratic coalition? Or will it dominated by the domineering Mahathir?”

Sivarajan ( pix ) said that as long as Umno-BN is in power, the rakyat will continue to suffer.

He also pointed out that Najib’s administration is a continuation of Mahathir’s authoritarian legacy, adding that the alliance to oust Najib only made both Harapan and civil society leaders the target of public criticism.

Even though the respective leaders were there in their personal capacity, Sivarajan said it would be difficult to draw the line between personal opinion and the organisation or political party that they represent.

“Did they ever consult their members on their decision? Did they insist that the declaration must be amended with their inputs before they inked it?" he asked.

He said many declarations had been made in the past but none had made any significant impact, adding that the downfall of tyrants like Ferdinand Marcos and Suharto was not achieved by declarations of the political elites alone.

He said that true change can only happen when a political system is replaced by another alternative system.

Yesterday, Mahathir together with opposition and civil society leaders signed a citizens' declaration calling for Najib to be removed from power by legal means and instituting reforms, though it did not advocate the removal of Umno-BN as the ruling government.

This has struck a discordant note in some circles, with many noting that the wily Mahathir has sidestepped some very important questions about the direction of the coalition.